Your data. Your choice.

If you select «Essential cookies only», we’ll use cookies and similar technologies to collect information about your device and how you use our website. We need this information to allow you to log in securely and use basic functions such as the shopping cart.

By accepting all cookies, you’re allowing us to use this data to show you personalised offers, improve our website, and display targeted adverts on our website and on other websites or apps. Some data may also be shared with third parties and advertising partners as part of this process.

Searchlight Pictures
Review

"Wild Horse Nine": See Rapa Nui ... and die?

Patrick Vogt
11/11/2026
Translation: machine translated

With "Wild Horse Nine," Martin McDonagh has once again delivered a magnificent film. At times, he draws from his own oeuvre, yet ultimately creates something unique. John Malkovich gives perhaps the performance of his life in it.

Don't worry: this film review is spoiler-free. I won't reveal anything more than what is already known and visible in the trailers. «Wild Horse Nine» hits theaters on November 12th.

The new film from director Martin McDonagh arrives in cinemas with a lot of advance praise. Various film festivals have already shown and celebrated «Wild Horse Nine», including the Zurich Film Festival. McDonagh also received an honorary award there. Consequently, I cannot help but praise him and «Wild Horse Nine» as well.

What it's about

Chile in 1973: The democratically elected socialist government of President Salvador Allende is faltering. In the midst of this, we follow two CIA agents, Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell), in Santiago de Chile. They are busy pulling strings in the background for the upcoming military coup by General Augusto Pinochet.

Shortly before the violent change of government, the two travel to Rapa Nui because Chris is desperate to see the Moai – the colossal stone statues. Chris is no longer a young man and is increasingly disillusioned with his intelligence work. Furthermore, he shows signs of dementia, wears his heart on his sleeve, and enjoys spilling internal secrets to complete strangers. That is why Lee accompanies him not only as a partner but also, on behalf of their boss MJ (Steve Buscemi), as a babysitter, or perhaps more accurately, a minder.

Lee is the only one who knows the true state of Chris's condition. And so, amidst the island idyll, not only is his loyalty put to the test, but also the question of how far he is willing to go for a friend. And Chris? Even though he is busy spilling secrets, he is still carrying his biggest one with him.

Chris's loose tongue gives MJ (Steve Buscemi) a headache.
Chris's loose tongue gives MJ (Steve Buscemi) a headache.
Source: Searchlight Pictures

Is it all nonsense or what?

Martin McDonagh is a master at telling and directing hilarious yet tragic stories with depth about male friendships. He proved this impressively with «In Bruges» and «The Banshees of Inisherin». In «Wild Horse Nine», he relies on this formula once again. That is precisely the film's greatest strength – and at the same time, its only minor weakness. The setting is new: instead of a timeless Belgium or a fictional Ireland, McDonagh places his story against the real backdrop of a CIA-backed military coup – giving it an unusually political weight.

«Wild Horse Nine» is a largely quiet film, interrupted only occasionally by sudden bursts of violence. It thrives on the relationship between the two main characters and their dialogue. When Chris and Lee go at each other verbally, it is screamingly funny, sarcastic, and sometimes just plain absurd. For example, at one point, Chris philosophizes about good cheese and what it has to do with the strength of a country's democracy. Or he simply explains where the Molotov cocktail got its name.

I wouldn't mind having an argument on Rapa Nui either.
I wouldn't mind having an argument on Rapa Nui either.
Source: Searchlight Pictures

In between, he repeatedly looks back on his life thoughtfully and wistfully, questioning his actions for the CIA. In doing so, he refers to events in which the US foreign intelligence service had a hand. This makes the film all the more interesting and, for some, even educational. That the USA has always liked to interfere in the affairs of other states is a historical fact. In the past, they at least tried to keep it a secret.

So far, so good. But if you are familiar with McDonagh's previous work, you will have long since recognized the mechanics behind it, despite the new, politically charged setting. While this still works excellently in «Wild Horse Nine», it feels a bit too familiar by now. That much criticism is necessary.

A one-man show – almost

In at least one respect, the film differs fundamentally from its two predecessors: instead of Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, John Malkovich («Of Mice and Men», «Being John Malkovich») and Sam Rockwell («Confessions of a Dangerous Mind», «Moon») take the lead roles. What the two deliver in «Wild Horse Nine» is acting of the highest caliber and is simply brilliant. Above all, Malkovich, who has proven so often throughout his career how versatile and adaptable he is.

Chris befriends student Monica (Mariana di Girolamo).
Chris befriends student Monica (Mariana di Girolamo).
Source: Searchlight Pictures

He embodies the disillusioned, life-worn CIA veteran Chris with a credibility that is second to none. He manages the shift between dry cynicism, childlike curiosity, and sudden melancholy with ease. Even though John Malkovich has never been bad, I haven't seen him this good in a long time – perhaps ever. At the Venice International Film Festival, he won the Coppa Volpi for Best Actor for «Wild Horse Nine». I'll go out on a limb and say that won't be his last award for this role.

The fact that Malkovich can flourish and shine so much in his role is also thanks to his sparring partner, Sam Rockwell. His Lee is increasingly overwhelmed and stressed by the situation, but time and again he stands up to Chris – and is always there when he is needed. Furthermore, Steve Buscemi («Fargo», «The Big Lebowski») elevates the cast as their nervous boss, as does Parker Posey («Clockwatchers», «The White Lotus») as Lee's apparently not-so-loyal wife. Oh, and did I mention Tom Waits («Down by Law», «Coffee and Cigarettes»)?

Parker Posey in her hilarious role as Lee's wife, Margie.
Parker Posey in her hilarious role as Lee's wife, Margie.
Source: Searchlight Pictures

In a nutshell

Great drama and dialogue-driven cinema with a sense of déjà vu

"Wild Horse Nine" is a wickedly mean, clever, and fantastically acted tragicomedy full of black humor and melancholy. Director Martin McDonagh remains true to his style with this one – perhaps a touch too true. Because anyone familiar with his earlier works eventually knows how the game is played. A little more surprise wouldn't have hurt, despite all the quality. Nevertheless, "Wild Horse Nine" is another masterpiece from McDonagh and easily one of the best films I have seen this year. And that also has to do with proven structures. But I just never get enough of sharp-witted dialogue and films whose mood shifts seamlessly between humor, drama, and suspense while always maintaining balance. The cast is in top form, led by John Malkovich, who delivers an Oscar-worthy performance. There, I said it.
Header image: Searchlight Pictures

42 people like this article


User Avatar
User Avatar

I'm a full-blooded dad and husband, part-time nerd and chicken farmer, cat tamer and animal lover. I would like to know everything and yet I know nothing. I know even less, but I learn something new every day. What I am good at is dealing with words, spoken and written. And I get to prove that here. 


Review

Which films, shows, books, games or board games are genuinely great? Recommendations from our personal experience.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Show all

These articles might also interest you

21 comments

Avatar
later